
Hello everyone,
and welcome to a new episode of the YourDailyGerman Online Grammar Course.
Last time, we learned about the normal conjugation in present tense that works for like 99% of all verbs.
Today, we’ll talk about the few verbs that are kind of “special needs”.
We could also call them
Irregular Verbs in German
Basically, there are nine verbs that use slightly different verb endings than the normal ones, and they also have a bit of a stem change going on.
And I guess it’s fair that they’d be special because they’re also the most important and most common verbs – haben, sein, werden, the modal verbs and, as a sort of bonus, wissen.
Today, we’ll go over them one by one, see how they conjugate and we’ll also learn a bit of trivia for each one.
Like, important differences to their English cousins and stuff we need to pay attention to when using them. Or just stuff like what’s their favorite food or what are they doing in their free time. You know… getting to know them a little.
Oh, and we’ll also say a few words about modal verbs in general because… it’s actually kind of a mess.
So, this will be a long article. We’re going long German, so to speak.
But long is the new short, right?

So, let’s jump right in with the first ones that are sein and haben.
***
Because those are the main helper verbs and we need them to form the past tense.
Conjugating “sein”
Most of you probably know that sein is the German verb for to be.
And it’s the only REALLY irregular verb German has….
- ich bin
- du bist
- er ist
- wir sind
- ihr seid
- sie sind
And actually, it’s the same in English. I mean, not the same forms, but English to be is just as “chaotic”.
to be – I am – he is
And then the past tense
I was – You were
These forms have virtually nothing in common. And there’s a surprising reason for that.
To be as well as German sein and their forms are actually a mix of several verbs that are about being in some way.
The German ich bin for instance is related to English to be. The forms are and is(t) as well as the German sein (with the “e” missing in the beginning) come from a different root – the same root as the word essence. And the past forms was and were were taken from a third verb
But you don’t really have to remember all that. I just thought it’s interesting to know WHY these two verbs are such an incredible patchwork.
What matters is that you remember how to conjugate it. And in fact, you can start right now, because we’ll do our first little quiz :)
That’s enough for now, but we’ll mix in more later as we train the other verbs.
Because my didactics are very strong, you know :).
Anyway … moving on.
Conjugating “haben”
Haben is the other really important helper verb but it’s way less irregular than sein. In fact, it’s almost regular except for one little change. Can you spot what it is :)?
- ich habe
- du hast
- sie hat
- wir haben
- ihr habt
- sie haben
The color gave a pretty strong hint. The irregularity here is the missing b for the second and third person singular. With the system we learned last time, it should be du habst and er/sie/es habt, but the b is not there. I can’t tell you why, to be honest. Pronouncing bst or bt does need some effort, and maybe the word was used so much, that the b got washed away. Whatever the reason may be, thankfully there is this famous Rammstein song “Du hast” – if you know it, then that’s a good way to remember the form.
And even if not, it’s really not that big of a deal. Just make sure to NOT say hast for third person (er/sie/es). It probably rolls off the tongue easily, because it’s he/she/it has in English, but in German… no s.
That said, let’s get right into some practice
Cool!
So now that we have those two out of the way, let’s get to the small group that really does have its own set of endings. Which in textbooks and courses is often referred to by the term modal verbs.
German Modal Verbs
And a few thoughts on that first.
Teachers and books use this term like everybody automatically knows what it is. But don’t feel bad, if you don’t. Why would you?
And the term doesn’t actually refer to the same verbs in all languages.
You see, German and English modal verbs are not the same.
Example: To want is NOT a modal verb in English, its German translation wollen IS a modal verb.
So if someone kind of just throws around the term modal verbs, you could totally ask which ones they mean… German or English?
And what’s also interesting is that the English Wikipedia, no doubt written by nerdy linguists, claims that French and other Roman languages don’t actually have modal verbs. And yet French courses do talk about French modal verbs like it’s canon.
So while being used as if it were a clearly defined term, in reality, “modal verb” is rather blurry.
There are not simply THE “modal verbs”. There are just “English modal verbs” and “German modal verbs” and they are not the same.
Now, that said, except for wissen, the verbs we’ll talk about now are the German Modal verbs.
And as I said, they conjugate slightly differently.
For one thing, the endings are a little bit different.
| normal verbs (lern-) | modal verbs (soll-) | |||
| stem | ending | stem | ending | |
| ich | lern- | e | soll- | — |
| du | lern- | st | soll- | st |
| er | lern- | t | soll- | — |
| wir | lern- | en | soll- | en |
| ihr | lern- | t | soll- | t |
| sie | lern- | en | soll- | en |
Not that bad, right?
The only difference really is that the ich and er/sie/es-forms don’t have an ending and look the same. We’ll actually also need this system of endings later on, once we get to the past tense, so I recommend you really think of it as a second system, rather than just as a bunch of exceptions.
But anyway, it’s not the only thing that makes these special verbs special.
There’s also a vowel change.
All the special verbs except for sollen change their stem-vowel for ich, du and er/sie/es. And it’s not a minor shift like we learned last time. You know… like schlafen that changes to schläfst, for example.
This time, we’re talking real change :).
What we’ll do now is look at the special verbs one by one, see (roughly) what they mean and look at the vowel change.
The Modal Verb können (kann- )
Können is the German brother of can, and this relationship is especially obvious in the stem change because ö goes to a.
Here’s the conjugation:
- ich kann
du kannst
er kann
wir können
ihr könnt
sie können
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
As we just learned, the plural forms behave completely regularly, but for the singular forms, we have the stem change and the slightly different endings ( [-] , [st], [-]).
As far as meaning goes, können is more broad than can, because it’s also the common translation for be able to. And just like can, it also extends into the realm of having permission.
The context usually makes it clear what the focus is, but Germans sometimes do goof around with it. Like in this classic
- Thomas : “Kannst du mir sagen wie spät es ist?
Maria: “Ja… … … ”
Thomas: “Und?”
Maria: “Was?”
Thomas: “Wie spät?”
Thomas wanted to know what time it is, but here, Maria misunderstood on purpose and answered whether she is capable of telling him what time it is. That’s one of the things Thomas really really likes about Maria. Her great, original sense of humor.
I’m kidding of course. He hates it when she does that.
Anyway, können often combines with another verb and this actually brings us to a really really really important new bit of info about German sentence structure.
Behold:
- Ich kann sehr gut Deutsch sprechen.
- I can speak German very well.
I think you all know what I mean… while in English, like in many other languages, the second verb comes right after can, in German it goes to the end.
And if you think back to last time, this is actually nothing new.
Do you remember the prefix verbs? It was the exact same thing there.
- Ich stehe um 10 auf.
- I get up at 10.
- Ich kann sehr gut Deutsch sprechen.
- I can speak German very well.
Because this is a universal feature of German: as soon as our verbal phrase has more than one part, the part that carries the ending sits in the “normal” spot, and the rest goes to the end.
We’ve had it with prefix verbs, now we see it with modal verbs, and we’ll see it again when we talk about the past tense. It’s not a weird special rule – it’s a core characteristic.But we’ll explore that more later in the course, once we get to word order.
For now, just remember that the combination of a modal verb with a normal verb behaves just like a prefix verb… one part stays put, the rest goes to the end.
It will take a while to get used to it so you will make mistakes. And that’s fine, people will still understand you. But please try to get it right, because it’s such an important feature.
Use the rhythm as a help. German often has this really crucial element at the end… a punch line if you will. That’s a different flow than English.
But anyway, here’s another example…
- Thomas kann sein Bier mit einem Feuerzeug aufmachen.
- I can open his beer with a lighter.
And now, it’s your turn again :).
Cool.
Moving on to the next one… and here, we’re in for some confusion.
The Modal Verb wollen (will-)
And I know what your brain is thinking. But it needs to stop!
Ich will does NOT mean I will.
It actually means I want.
And this makes perfect sense if you think of the English noun the will. Like… the will of the people. That’s about what people want.
The English word will just slowly shifted. Like… maybe at first people just wanted to sound very determined. Like… “I want to have a beer and you can’t stop me”. And then fully focused on actually making a statement about the future and completely lost the notion of wanting.
Anyway, the German wollen means to want and it could be really confusing if you use it as a translation for the English verb will. So my pro tipp is : don’t do it.
#helpful.
Seriously though… just try to associate German wollen with free will. Or volition, if you will.
Anyway, here’s the full conjugation:
- ich will
- du willst
- er/sie/es will
- wir wollen
- ihr wollt
- sie wollen
And here it is in a couple of examples.
- Ich will ein cooles Fahrrad.
- I want a cool bike.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
- Ich will ein kaltes Bier trinken.
- I want to drink a cold beer.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
And as you can see, the structure is the same as for können. So if we have a second verb, it goes to the end.
Cool, quick practice and then we’ll get to the next one.
The Modal Verb müssen (muss-)
Also this one looks familiar. And in this case, it’s not a trap. Müssen means must and it’s also THE translation for to have to. Don’t try to translate that with haben. It can work sometimes, but it can also be really confusing.
Müssen is the way to go for obligations.
- Ich muss jetzt gehen.
- I must leave now.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
- Ich muss morgen zur Universität gehen.
- I have to go to the university tomorrow.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
As you can see, for the vowel change we just have to go from ü to u, and müssen would be a piece of cake.
If it wasn’t for one little issue: the thing that happens when you negate the verb.
Take a look at these two sentences.
- I must open the window.
- I have to open the window.
They’re pretty much the same, right?
Now let’s see what happens when we negate them.
- I mustn’t open the window.
- I don’t have to open the window.
Now, they’re different.
The first one tells us that there is an obligation to NOT OPEN the window. We must leave it closed.
The second one on the other hand tells us that there is NO obligation to OPEN the window. It’s okay if I leave it closed.
And German müssen actually behaves like to have to.
So this sentence…
- Ich muss nicht das Fenster öffnen.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
is a translation for the second sentence, NOT for the first one.
Let’s do another example. Take this sentence:
- Du musst nicht abwaschen. Ich mache das später.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
Does that mean that you must not do the dishes or that you don’t have to do it?
Exactly, it’s the latter.
If we want to actually express must not, then we need dürfen. We’ll get to that next, but first I want to tell you about one particular useful phrase with müssen…
- Ich muss mal.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
Taken literally, this is a casual sounding “I have to”, and the meaning is clear to everyone… it means that you need to go to the bathroom.
Cool. So now before we get to the next verb, it’s time for another little quiz.
What? Oh, you wonder about the full conjugation for müssen?
Well, as I said… it’s time for another little quiz ;).
The Modal Verb dürfen (darf-)
Unlike the words we had so far, dürfen actually doesn’t really have a relative in English. There used to be one, but that’s a long long time ago.
The core idea of dürfen is expressing permission. So it could be translated to can or may.
- Mama, darf ich heute abend fernsehen?
- Mom, can I watch TV tonight?
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
Actually, I think it’s closer to can, because it doesn’t sound as formal as may. Just keep in mind that the core idea is permission, not opportunity or capability.
You could technically also use können to express that, but dürfen is generally more clear, and in questions, it’s more polite sounding than können.
- In der Bar kann man rauchen.
- In der Bar darf man rauchen.
- In this bar one can/may/is allowed to smoke.
- Darf ich mal eure Toilette benutzen? (if you want to ask at a restaurant, for example)
- Could I use your restroom?
And as I alluded earlier, dürfen is also the word we need if we want to translate must not.
Taken literally, nicht dürfen means to not have permission, but it’s also used in contexts where there isn’t really a permission involved, but rather a “natural imperative” as you can see in the second example.
- You must not say that to Maria.
- Du darfst Maria das nicht sagen. (actual lack of permission)
- We have to get up early tomorrow. We must not watch Netflix till four ‘o clock today.
- Wir müssen morgen früh aufstehen. Wir dürfen heute nicht bis um 4 Netflix gucken.
I’d say nicht dürfen sounds less dramatic than must not, but still it’s a pretty fitting translation most of the time.
Cool.
So that’s dürfen :).
Here’s the full conjugation, just so you get to hear some umlaut….
- ich darf, du darfst, er darf,
wir dürfen, ihr dürft, sie dürfen
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
And here’s the quiz.
And on we go to the next one…
The Modal Verb mögen (mag-)
Mögen isn’t all that revealing but the form with the vowel change, mag, kind of gives it away – historically, mögen is the German brother of the English verb may. The core of this family is actually potential, so it seems to be the same idea as for the family of können and can.
But that family is actually about potential based on knowledge, which itself is actually related to can.
The branch of may/mögen on the other hand was about actual power. And we can still see that in the English word mighty or the German die Macht (the might, the power) or the Bulgarian мощ (“mosht”), which will be similar in other Slavic languages.
But for some reason the word may softened over the years and shifted toward a potential and sometimes even borders on permission.
- Only the worthy may lift that hammer. (original meaning about power)
- It may/might rain tomorrow. (potential)
- You may go now. (permission)
Quite the journey. But the German mögen actually went further because BY FAR its main meaning nowadays is… drumroll… to like.
- Ich mag dich. Magst du mich auch?
- I like you. Do you like me too?
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
- Thomas mag Bier sehr.
- Thomas likes beer a lot.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
And this of course raises the following: excuse me, wtf?
Or in other words, how do you get from potential and power to liking.
Well, all you need is to put your mind a nice painful yoga pose. Something we’ll do a LOT on this site, by the way.
It started with the negated version nicht mögen. Originally, it expresses that you don’t have the potential, but then it shifted toward not having the desire. If you need help, just think of taxes. Lots of people who don’t want to pay say they can’t pay.
But yeah… this sense of wanting caught on, and eventually the verb shifted toward wanting and from there toward liking.
Tadah… German logic, fellahs. You better get used to it.
Now, the original sense of mögen is actually still around and you can find it here and there. But it’s not worth worrying about in a beginner’s lesson. The main meaning is to like and that’s enough for now. Trust me.
As per usualy, here the complete conjugation:
- ich mag, du magst, er mag,
wir mögen, ihr mögt, sie mögen
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
And if you think we’ll do the quizz now, you’re actually mistaken because we’ll move right on to sollen.
The Modal Verb sollen (soll-)
Sollen doesn’t have a vowel change, but it still might be the one that is the hardest one to handle.
The core idea is obligation, but it’s a very specific kind. Müssen was also about obligation, if you remember, but that could be an obligation by reality. Like… I must go to bed now, if I want to be awake tomorrow.
Sollen specifically expresses an obligation coming from someone. Someone tells you what to do.
The most famous example are probably the 10 commandments, where God tells us what we have to do.
- Du sollst nicht zuviel Netflix gucken.
- Thou shalt not watch too much Netflix.**
(**sample commandment, might not actually come from God)
And here we also see the English counterpart of sollen: shall. Shall kind of does have the same idea but its tone is quite different and I think it’s better to think of sollen as “to be supposed to/obliged to”.
And let’s not even mention should now. I can actually kind of promise you that you will be confused about sollen and sollte and should at some point in your learning journey. But not today, as they say :).
One thing though… you might already know the word Entschuldigung which is one of the GErman ways to say sorry, excuse me. Well… guess where that comes from
- Ent-schuld-igung
- “De-should-ification”
The word die Schuld is the German word for guilt and debt and that kind of is … an obligation toward someone.
Anyway, enough with the trivia.
So sollen is about an obligation that comes from a person. But is often also translated as to have to.
- Mein Arzt hat gesagt, ich soll viel trinken.
- My doctor said, I have to drink a lot.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
- Ich bin aufgeregt. Ich soll morgen ein Referat halten.
- I am nervous. I have to do a presentation tomorrow.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
In both examples, you can actually replace it with müssen, and I think for now it might be enough if you just understand sollen and know that it exists. But just as the 4th commandment of German learning says.
4. Thou shalt not stress out about when to use sollen.
Cool.
The complete conjugation is of course really boring, because there isn’t even a vowel change. So let’s jump right into the quiz.
Oh and make sure you still know your mögen :)
All right.
And now let’s get to the last word for today.
The Verb wissen (weiß-)
Wissen is a relative of the English wisdom and wit and it’s one of the two German verbs for to know. Yes, German has two. The other one is kennen and at you will have a lot of fun trying to learn what the difference is. Well, unless you speak a Romance language like French or Italian or a Slavic language like Bulgarian, because they all also have two verbs. It’s English that is kind of weird in this case.
Anywho… for today let’s just say that wissen is used for actual factual facts and kennen is for people, names and stories.
Now, wissen actually is neither a helper verb nor a modal verb but for some reason it does conjugate like them. So it uses the endings we have learned today, and it also has a unique surprise vowel change –
from “i” to “ei”.
Doesn’t look very different, but it sounds very different.
Let’s look at some examples
- Ich weiß nicht.
- I don’t know.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
Oh and then there’s of course this weird letter ß. This is called “s-z” or sharp s or, and this is my personal favorite, Rucksack-s. A Rucksack is a backpack so it is an s with another s in its backpack.
Germans use it if they need a sharp “s” after a long vowel, because usually “ss” makes a vowel short.
But honestly, that’s NOTHING to worry about for a young fledgling like you :).
You can just type ss and most people won’t even really notice.
So, let’s look at some more examples…
- Ich weiß viel über Berlin.
- I know a lot about Berlin.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
- “Chris ist ein Idiot”
“Ich weiß…” - “Chris is an idiot.”‘
“I know…” - Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
- Ich weiß, dass ich nichts weiß.
- I know that I don’t know anything.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
- Wissen Sie, wann der Bus kommt?
- Do you know, when comes the bus?
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
Did you notice how we used a couple of new phrasings in the last two examples? A question and a that sentence. That’s because you’re actually advancing toward B2 level now. Well, okay…. not that advanced, but we’re almost done with conjugation and you’re ready for useful, real phrasings. But first, let’s finish this off properly.
Here’s the full conjugation…
- ich weiß, du weißt, er weiß,
wir wissen, ihr wisst, sie wissen
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
And I hope you paid attention to the du-form in particular because I will soooo ask you about it in the quiz now :)
Well… soon. Once it’s done.
Wrapping up
So this is it… these are our special verbs, with their special conjugation and their even more special vowel changes.
Just a quick reminder:
- wollen – will
- können – kann
- müssen – muss
- dürfen – darf
- sollen – soll
- mögen – mag
- wissen – weiß
Now, throughout the article, we’ve already seen and practiced the whole verb at the end thing, but I wanted to give you just one more example to show just how wide this split can really be.
- Thomas kann morgen nicht mit seiner Freundin Maria, mit der er seit 2 Jahren zusammen ist, zu der von allen Kritikern gefeierten Aufführung von Hamlet ins neueröffnete Theater gehen.
- Thomas cannot go to the critically acclaimed representation of Hamlet in the new theater with his girlfriend Maria whom he has been dating for 2 years.
- Practice pronunciation – click once to start recording and again to stop
That’s some serious cirque du soleil split right there :).
Seriously, I bet this looks scary to you, but you’ll get used to it. And then it’s actually kind of fun.
The sentence or phrase has a defined ending, no matter how it looks. If you cut the part about how long he has been dating her, the German sentence is just shorter but still ends the same way.
This verb-at-the-end-thing really gives some gravity to the end of the sentence. It doesn’t just end at some point. It ends with what’s most important. This is also a reason why German politicians appear to be very good listeners. Truth is, they just can’t interrupt, because they can’t know what the other one is saying…. sure… you can anticipate a LOT. But a German needs this final verb. It makes him feel well.
If you forget it, it will feel incomplete, if you say it too early your sentence is not that interesting anymore.. there is no more suspense in it.
Even if it makes your brain bend,
put the verb’s leftovers at the end.
Yeah… that is so poetic. I think we’re done for today… the words in this article are ESSENTIAL for German, so make sure you understood everything. If not it is probably because the explanation sucks. Just leave me a comment and I’ll see to it.
Next time, we will talk about how to ask questions… in German.
Till then take care.

In the quiz, Du darfst das nicht machen. the correct answer according to the context should be You’re not allowed to do that, but it’s incorrect, I couldn’t understand this…
The question is asking which option is NOT a translation.
I just finished this lesson after several days… because of procastination >D It’s fun! After finishing this lesson, I got to familiarized the conjugation more. The quizzes are really helpful to make me realize “girl you forgot it again!” but I eventually answered them correctly (without looking at the notes). Just hoping I can remember them still eventually haha! Off to the next lesson…
Thanks
How do you know which size is singular and which plural?
Hello. I am confuse about “German can be very confusing.” Can you explain why it is “sein” instead of “ist”? I was thinking ist because German pronoun can be “It” Do we use Sein for not person/not “it” nouns?
Help me out please, what are you referring to?
Do you mean “Deutsch kann sehr verwirrend sein?”
I meant sie
From the context and the conjugations. If I give you a task like “Gestern ____ sie mich angerufen.” and you’re supposed to fill in the verb, you cannot, because there’s no way for you to know whether it’s singular or plural.
Does that help?
Yes. I understand your answer. These nouns should always have the base form, is it? Deutsch – sein in instance?
Ah, no, the conjugated verb here is “kann”.
– Deutsch kann blah blah blah.
“sein” is attached to “kann”.
Does that help?
Okay. Have to go back to the “Sein” lesson as I was confused. Need to study more! >D But appreciate your response!! Makes me want to study harder!
Study not harder, but “presenter”. Be present when you study and be aware of what you’re doing and why. Your brain does most of the work if you give it the right conditions and being calm is very helpfu. No pressure.
Small comment, The S in Sie (3 person plurals) is not always capitalized and it’s a little confusing.
The capitalized version is the polite singular “you”, while small one is plural “they”. In the beginning of a sentence, both of them are capitalized. Does that help or did I mix things up somewhere?
Hello Emanuel,
Thank you for this wonderful course. I had more of a technical curiosity, how are the audio’s graded, I mean is there some sound model or API I can look into.
There is a model, but it’s not mine, it comes from EF languages, but I think they shut down development on it a while ago.
The audios are graded along 4 dimensions, like rhythm, tone, and two others. I forgot. I do get the fine grained grading but I decided not to display it when I integrated this feature here. It’s been years.
It does really really well with me as a native speaker. So it scores me 100 even if I mumble or speak fast. So it “knows” what native is.
It does not use audio. Grading is based straight on the written sentence.
Awesome thanks, that feeds my technical curiosity, coming from Informatik background ;)
Can “must not” ever be translated with “müssen”?
Yes, it depends on the context.
Yes, it depends on the moon cycle.
Nope.
in the above question why option 1 is incorrect?
chatgpt says option 1 is correct i also think its right
it gives following rationale;
for PROHIBITION- NICHT DUERFEN
for LOGICAL CONCLUSION- NICHT MUESSEN IS USED
could you please explain? thank you
Hmm, I guess you can make it work for assumption-conclusions.
– He must not have eaten his food.
– Er muss sein Essen nicht gegessen haben.
“müssen” CAN express that, but in most instances a native speaker would not phrase it this way because it’s too ambiguous sounding.
So I guess I need to rephrase this question a bit.
ok! thank you.
i have doubt in the following question;
Now let’s deal with some sentences.
What’s the proper translation for:
“Thomas wants to be taller.”
ans; thomas will gruoesser sein
But here
why cant i use IST instead of SEIN at the end
because be form of er is IST and not SEIN right?
Only one verb is ever conjugated, same as in English where you wouldn’t say this:
– Thomas wants to is taller
What Thomas “does” is “wanting”, and the “being” is just a specification for wanting. Does that help?
Yeah got it!!
You’re really an amazing teacher man!
Thank you
Happy to help.
This lesson was amazing as always Emmanuel. I am an absolute beginner and I think sometimes I get lost in the order of sentences in some examples, should I put the essentials section on hold for a while and complete sentence order and come back? Is there any preferred section order for complete beginners like me? If so, please do let me know.
Do completely the essentials first, would be my recommendation.
But if you feel super curious about sentence structure, you need to follow that curiosity. Do start with “sentence structure” though, and the first part of “word order”. NOT part 2 and 3 of word order. Those need an edit, they’re a bit outdated.
Thanks for the immediate reply Emmanuel. Will follow your suggestion of starting with the first part of sentence structure and word order, and come back here.
Your explanations definitely do not suck! This is excellent! I am so happy to have found your site.
Danke :)!
difference between “must” and “don’t have to” is tricking me up pretty good.
You mean “must not” vs “don’t have to”, right?
I just think of it as required and not required. That made it easier to wrap my head around.
Oh, that’s a great way to think about it!!
awesome! not overwhelmed AT ALL :,)
In Dürfen test, Question 4: I think the answer key is wrong. Currently “Du darfst das nicht machen.” Is translated as “You don’t have to do that” instead of You are not allowed to do that.
The question is asking which of the three options is NOT a translation, so that would be the version with “don’t have to”.
Ugh. And this is why I never made a 100% on any test at any time in my school life. Thank you
Thanks for this excellent course. I just completed this section. I found the grammar to be very clearly explained, systematic, and the routine tests and repetitions are very useful. If one just learns a thing on one day, and does not repeat it, then they will forget. That’s what makes your method of teaching so useful – because you test us and make us repeat the verbs. Thanks immensely!
Thanks for the great feedback! I’m actually thinking about adding a more proper course format to this, where the lessons are broken down by segment, so you don’t have to come back to the same article all the time.
Lots of work, but I think it’s time!
I am on a 543 day streak on Duolingo have not learned the why of any of it. After a certain point, everything is just a guess. If anyone else does Duolingo, you will understand when I say that I am fighting with Lily lately. She is intentionally unhelpful and if she rolls her Augen at me one more time, I cannot be responsible for my actions.
I think I have to revisit Duo. Much seems to have changed since I last didn’t like it.
So I have now used Duolingo for like 24 days (Streak wohooo) and the didactics are piss poor. In the final “lesson” of a waypoint or whatever they call the circles, I suddenly get confronted with a bunch of vocab I have never seen AND grammar concepts that were never explained. I can get it right by using common sense mostly but I still have no clue why something was right. It’s truly awful!
I recently turned down writing a review for LingoDeer because I felt like it’s just like Duolingo. Well, now, after trying Duolingo again, I realize that LingoDeer is what DuoLingo USED to be and better.
I might have to crawl back to them and apologize for what I said :D
Lingopie is more of a resource to get vocab (and passively pick up some grammar maybe?) by watching shows, is it not? It’s nice to have some more interactive subtitles with it, but it still needs a fair bit of work when it comes to German.
They have something doing speech to text for the subtitles, and when words are mumbled a bit or aren’t what it is expecting to hear, it can get things wrong. I was watching Star Wars: Young Jedi Adventures and there’s a droid named RJ-83. In one episode alone I heard it say “RJ” four different ways. One was correct, and the other three were guesses at words it made up because the dialog had a lot of background noise.
In another episode, there was some animal making random noises and grunts and it somehow got subtitles about insurance…? I flagged those things.
I keep checking back every so often. It has some potential for what it is, it just needs help.
I’m still using Duolingo for some practice along with an in person class I’m taking, but I certainly don’t get as much from it as I do from these blogs or some instructional YouTube channels. These are great, and it looks like he just started along his goal of making separate lessons for each of the modal verbs because I just got an email about “sollen.”
Damn it… I meant LingoDEER, not LingoPIE. I keep mixing these two up.
Yes, LingoPie is a very different product from Duolingo, like you said.
I haven’t tried LingoPIe, but my guess is that they’re using STT (speech to text) AI tech to create the subtitles now. It’s MUCH more efficient than doing it by hand.
Since we’re on that topic, a person on Reddit recently told me about their project:
https://fluentai.pro/
It’s a browser extension that does what LingoPie does, but cheaper and on ALL kinds of streaming platforms.
I’ll also share it in my advent calendar, but I thought, I’d tell you directly here.
LingoPie’s extension used to work with some other services like Disney Plus and Netflix but now they don’t have it up and they’ve got some post about it being down until further notice. I’m not sure what exactly happened there but that means for now that I honestly wouldn’t recommend LingoPie because you’re stuck with only their catalog. I will have to check out that extension you linked.
” because you’re stuck with only their catalog.”
That makes the app virtually worthless, imo.
Yup, it does. It was nice when they had the plugin. One can only hope they’ll get that back but, it really is not worth it now. Oh well.
I tried FluentAI but they dont have a mobile app and I am on the road a lot for work so I decided to go with LangPanda instead to study German https://langpanda.com , will let you know how it goes, so far so good.
I used duo for a couple years when I first started learning German. I actually found it quite helpful, however I did a lot of side research on things I didn’t understand. when I used it, it did a great job at explaining basics like conjugating verbs, and it really helped me get comfortable with the cases. However, duo is limited in what it can do. I think it’s great to get a feel of a language, but to understand it, you need to go elsewhere.
yup, this.
the quiz belongs to the können part does not show results after submitting each question answer whether it was right or not. I had to view the results after finishing it.
Fixed it, thank you!!
Back when I made a lot of these, I didn’t think about how it would be more helpful to have the answer right away. There are probably more like this out there, so if you see another one, do let me know and I’ll change the settings.
sure. they are definitely so helpful. i really like the structure of the content:)
Hahaha your jokes always make my day, seriously I’ve been struggling to stick to German learning because of its complexity but you make it very enjoyable! Sorry if not the right place to leave this comment! Also you missed an exercise for Wissen hehe
Thanks for the nice feedback :).
Much appreciated.
is there a difference between wollen and mögen? like in which context to use one word or if they give a different vibe?
“wollen” is “to want”, “mögen” is “to like”. They’re pretty different to my native speaker brain. Why do you feel like they could be the same?
Like, if i were to say “ich möchte x“ and „ich will x“ they both mean like “i want to have x”
Yeah, but that’s “möchten”, not “mögen”. “möchten” is a more polite but also more formal sounding version.
“Ich moechte ein Bier.”
“Ich will ein Bier.”
“Ich mag ein Bier.”
#1 and #2 are pretty close. Both will work. What about #3?
It doesn’t work when you order one.
Sometimes people say that especially in questions “Magst du ein Bier?”, but that’s HIGHLY colloquial and learners really shouldn’t start doing this until they’re fluent and comfy with the normal use of modal verbs. That’s why I don’t bring up these kinds of nuances here :)
Ich verstehe. Danke.
(BTW, I am using an iPad to access these lessons. My spellchecker keeps changing things when I write auf Deutsch. Do you know how to fix that?)
No idea, I’m not an Apple person, but it’ll probably be somewhere in your keyboard settings that you can set languages you type in.
It’s 2026, it should recognize that automatically but oh well :)
regarding haben and its imperfect subjunctive hätte-nä
Q. in the phrase ‘ich hätte ein …’
does this literally mean i have liking for a …?
Do you mean when people order something?
Like:
– Ich hätte ein Bier.
To me, this sounds super awkward, but I do hear people saying it. To me, it’s just “hätte gern” with “gern” missing.